@prefix bibo: . @prefix bido: . @prefix dc: . @prefix dcterms: . @prefix foaf: . @prefix ns1: . @prefix ns2: . @prefix ns3: . @prefix owl: . @prefix prov: . @prefix rdf: . @prefix rdfs: . @prefix reg: . @prefix schema: . @prefix skos: . @prefix time: . @prefix vann: . @prefix vs: . @prefix xsd: . dc:contributor a owl:AnnotationProperty . dc:creator a owl:AnnotationProperty . dc:date a owl:AnnotationProperty . dc:description a owl:AnnotationProperty . dc:rights a owl:AnnotationProperty . dc:title a owl:AnnotationProperty . a owl:Ontology ; rdfs:label "Bibliometric Data Ontology (BiDO)" ; dc:contributor "Sebastian Barzaghi (https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0799-1527)"^^xsd:string ; dc:creator "Enrico Motta (https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0015-1952)", "Francesco Osborne (https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6557-3131)", "Silvio Peroni (http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0530-4305)" ; dc:date "2026-08-14" ; dc:description """ The **_Bibliometric Data Ontology (BiDO)_** is a modular OWL 2 ontology that allows the description of bibliometric data in RDF. ![](bido.png) The [**_core_**](http://purl.org/spar/bido-core) module of the ontology allows us to describe any entity and the related bibliometric data (through the property `bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime`) at a certain time (i.e., `tvc:atTime`, a property defined by the imported [TVC ontology design pattern](http://purl.org/spar/tvc) for specifying temporal instants or intervals) and according to a certain agent (through the property `bido:accordingTo`, which is a sub-property of `prov:wasAttributedTo` and allows us to indicate the agent responsible for such bibliometric data). In addition, BiDO imports PROV-O for adding provenance data about the activities related to the creation of such bibliometric data. Two alternative kinds of bibliometric data are specifiable (through the property `bido:withBibliometricData`) in BiDO: numeric and categorial bibliometric data. Numeric bibliometric data are those characterised by a certain integer or float value related to a particular bibliometric measure, while categorial data are those characterised by the assignment of certain categories to a particular bibliographic resource. ![](bido-core.png) Currently, BiDO is composed by three different modules, each extending the core one. [**_Standard bibliometric measures._**](http://purl.org/spar/bido-standard-bibliometric-measures) This module defines a list of possible bibliometric measures that can be used to define bibliometric data of publication-related entities, e.g.: h-index, e-index, journal impact factor, author citation count. ![](bido-standard-bibliometric-measures.png) [**_Research career chategories._**](http://purl.org/spar/bido-research-career-category) This module extends the class `bido:CategorialBibliometricData` of the core module with specific categories describing the research career of people described in terms of the specific facets: * the research period considered, i.e., the interval of research years that the algorithm is taking into consideration (e.g., the first 5/10 years); * the kind of curve of the citations received by an author according to the aforementioned period, which is characterised by a trend (flat/increasing/decreasing) and, in the latter two cases, by an acceleration or deceleration point (none or premature, median, overdue acceleration/deceleration); * the slope of such curve, in terms of strength (low/moderate/high) and kind of growth (linear/polynomial/exponential/logarithmic); * the order of magnitude, which categorises the number of citations received in the considered period according to a uniform model of common-sense estimation, which describes intervals of half-order of magnitude – i.e., “[0,1)”, “[1,3)”, “[3,9)”, “[9,27)”, “[27,81)”, “[81,243)”, “[243,729)”, etc. ![](bido-research-career-category.png) [**_Review measures._**](http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures) The need of describing aspects related to the review process is an important aspect to address by publishers (e.g., Springer) for keeping track of crucial information about conferences and journals. In addition, these data can be crucial for assessing the quality of the venues where researchers publish papers. This module of BiDO describes a list of possible reviews measures tha can be used to define bibliometric data of scholarly venues such as conferences, workshops, and journals. ![](bido-review-measures.png) ## Examples of use In the following subsections, we introduce some examples to showcase how to use BiDO. The prefixes that are used in all the examples provided below are defined as follows: @prefix : . @prefix bido: . @prefix cito: . @prefix conf: . @prefix fabio: . @prefix foaf: . @prefix frbr: . @prefix journal: . @prefix onto: . @prefix rdfs: . @prefix time: . @prefix tvc: . @prefix xsd: . ### Specifying the impact factor of a journal Numeric bibliometric data are those characterised by a certain integer or float value related to a particular bibliometric measure. BiDO allows one to specify these measures – e.g., h-index, author citation count, e-index, and journal impact factor – to bibliographic resources. For instance, in the following example we assign the 2014 Impact Factor to the Journal of Web Semantics. journal:journal-of-web-semantics a fabio:Journal ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :web-semantics-if-2014 . :web-semantics-if-2014 a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :2015-validity-period ; bido:accordingTo :thomson-reuters ; bido:withBibliometricData :web-semantics-if-2014-value . :2015-validity-period a time:Interval ; time:hasBeginning :2015-01-01 ; time:hasEnd :2015-12-31 . :web-semantics-if-2014-value a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:journal-impact-factor ; bido:hasNumericValue "2.464"^^xsd:float . :thomson-reuters a foaf:Organization ; foaf:homepace . ### Assigning a research career category to a person The module of BiDO for describing research career chategories allows one to assign specific categories describing kinds of research careers to people, as described in the following paper: Osborne, F., Peroni, S., Motta, E. (2014). Clustering Citation Distributions for Semantic Categorization and Citation Prediction. In Zhao, J., van Erp, M., Keßler, C., Kauppinen, T., van Ossenbruggen, J., van Hage, W. R. (Eds.), Proceedings of the 4th Workshop on Linked Science (LISC 2014), CEUR Workshop Proceedings 1282: 24–35. Aachen, Germany: CEUR-WS.org. http://ceur-ws.org/Vol-1282/lisc2014_submission_9.pdf For instance, in the example we assign a particular research category (defined mainly by mathematical and geometrical features) to John Doe. :john-doe a foaf:Person ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :5-years-research-career . :5-years-research-career a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :since-july-2014 ; bido:accordingTo :research-career-algorithm ; bido:withBibliometricData :increasing-with-prem-dec-and-low-log-slope-in-243-729-5-y-beg . :since-july-2014 a time:Interval ; time:hasBeginning :2014-07-11 . :research-career-algorithm a fabio:Algorithm ; cito:isDescribedBy ; frbr:realization :algorithm-implementation . :algorithm-implementation a fabio:ComputerProgram . :increasing-with-prem-dec-and-low-log-slope-in-243-729-5-y-beg a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :increasing-curve-with-premature-deceleration ; bido:hasSlope :low-logarithmic-slope ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:243-729 ; bido:concernsResearchPeriod bido:5-years-beginning . :increasing-curve-with-premature-deceleration a bido:Curve ; bido:hasTrend bido:increasing ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint :premature-deceleration . :low-logarithmic-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasStrength bido:low ; bido:hasGrowth bido:logarithmic . ### Conference rank and average of reviews per paper This example shows how to use BiDO for describing numeric and categorial bibliometric data related to a conference, i.e., the '5th International Conference on Automated Deduction'. In particular, we specify average number of reviews per paper and the conference ranking that the conference has. The particular module used for specifying such data is the Review Measures module. conf:cade1980 a onto:Conference ; rdfs:label "5th International Conference on Automated Deduction" ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime conf:cade1980-avg-num-reviews-per-paper , conf:cade1980-cff-rank . conf:cade1980-avg-num-reviews-per-paper a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; rdfs:label "3 reviews per paper on average (according to Springer)" ; bido:withBibliometricData conf:cade1980-numeric-data-avg-num-reviews-per-paper ; bido:accordingTo :springer . :springer a foaf:Organization ; rdfs:label "Springer" ; foaf:homepage . conf:cade1980-numeric-data-avg-num-reviews-per-paper a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; rdfs:label "3 reviews per paper on average" ; bido:hasNumericValue "3"^^xsd:integer ; bido:hasMeasure bido:average-of-reviews-per-paper . conf:cade1980-cff-rank a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; rdfs:label "B (according to CORE)" ; tvc:atTime :2015-validity-period ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:core-b ; bido:accordingTo :core . :2015-validity-period a time:Interval ; time:hasBeginning :2015-01-01 ; time:hasEnd :2015-12-31 . :core a foaf:Organization ; rdfs:label "Computing Research and Education Association of Australasia" ; foaf:homepage . ## Competency Questions BiDO can be used for answering several questions related to bibliometric data. In the following subsections, some of them are introduced together with their respective SPARQL queries. The prefixes that are used in all the SPARQL queries provided below are defined as follows: PREFIX bido: PREFIX foaf: PREFIX tvc: PREFIX time: ### CQ1 What numeric bibliometric data are held by an entity, and according to which source? SELECT ?entity ?dataSituation ?source ?measure ?numericValue WHERE { ?entity bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ?dataSituation . ?dataSituation a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; bido:withBibliometricData ?bibliometricData . ?bibliometricData a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure ?measure ; bido:hasNumericValue ?numericValue . OPTIONAL { ?dataSituation bido:accordingTo ?source . } } ### CQ2 What is the validity time interval for bibliometric data held in time? SELECT ?entity ?dataSituation ?startDate ?endDate WHERE { ?entity bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ?dataSituation . ?dataSituation a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime ?timeInterval . OPTIONAL { ?timeInterval time:hasBeginning ?startDate . } OPTIONAL { ?timeInterval time:hasEnd ?endDate . } } ### CQ3 Which research career category and detailed trajectory features are assigned to a person? SELECT ?person ?category ?trend ?slopeStrength ?slopeGrowth ?orderOfMagnitude ?period WHERE { ?person a foaf:Person ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ?dataSituation . ?dataSituation bido:withBibliometricData ?category . ?category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory . OPTIONAL { ?category bido:hasCurve ?curve . ?curve bido:hasTrend ?trend . } OPTIONAL { ?category bido:hasSlope ?slope . ?slope bido:hasStrength ?slopeStrength ; bido:hasGrowth ?slopeGrowth . } OPTIONAL { ?category bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude ?orderOfMagnitude . } OPTIONAL { ?category bido:concernsResearchPeriod ?period . } } ### CQ4 Which algorithms or organizations produce or evaluate bibliometric data held by an entity? SELECT ?entity ?dataSituation ?source ?sourceType WHERE { ?entity bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ?dataSituation . ?dataSituation a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; bido:accordingTo ?source . OPTIONAL { ?source a ?sourceType . } } ### CQ5 What categorical bibliometric rankings or measures (such as conference ranks or categorical reviews) are assigned to an entity? SELECT ?entity ?dataSituation ?bibliometricData ?source WHERE { ?entity bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ?dataSituation . ?dataSituation a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; bido:withBibliometricData ?bibliometricData . OPTIONAL { ?dataSituation bido:accordingTo ?source . } FILTER NOT EXISTS { ?bibliometricData a bido:NumericBibliometricData . } } """@en ; dc:title "The Bibliometric Data Ontology (BiDO)" ; dcterms:bibliographicCitation "Osborne, F., Peroni, S., Motta, E. (2014). Clustering Citation Distributions for Semantic Categorization and Citation Prediction. In Proceedings of the 4th Workshop on Linked Science (LISC 2014): 24–35. http://ceur-ws.org/Vol-1282/lisc2014_submission_9.pdf" ; dcterms:created "2014-08-11" ; dcterms:issued "2015-07-13" ; dcterms:license ; dcterms:modified "2026-08-14" ; dcterms:publisher ; dcterms:source ; bibo:doi "https://doi.org/10.25504/FAIRsharing.d7f0a9" ; bibo:status ; vann:changes """ * **v1.2.1**: Added new documentation, including annotation properties (e.g., `bibo:doi`, `schema:codeRepository`, etc.), term properties (e.g., `vann:example`, `vs:term_status`, etc.), exemplary competency questions with their respective SPARQL queries, and a Grafoo diagram. """@en ; vann:preferredNamespacePrefix "bido"@en ; vann:preferredNamespaceUri "http://purl.org/spar/bido"@en ; rdfs:seeAlso ; owl:backwardCompatibleWith bido:2015-07-13 ; owl:imports , , ; owl:priorVersion bido:2015-07-13 ; owl:versionIRI bido:2026-08-14 ; owl:versionInfo "1.2.1" ; foaf:logo ; schema:codeRepository ; schema:image , , , , ; schema:includedInDataCatalog ; schema:keywords "bibliometric data"@en, "bibliometrics"@en, "scholarly publishing"@en, "scientometrics"@en, "semantic publishing"@en . bido:0-1 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[0,1)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:0-1 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 0 (included) and 1 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:1-3 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[1,3)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:1-3 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 1 (included) and 3 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:10-years-beginning a owl:NamedIndividual, time:Interval ; rdfs:label "10 years beginning"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:concernsResearchPeriod bido:10-years-beginning . """ ; rdfs:comment "The interval covering the first 10 years of a research career."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:15-years-beginning a owl:NamedIndividual, time:Interval ; rdfs:label "15 years beginning"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:concernsResearchPeriod bido:15-years-beginning . """ ; rdfs:comment "The interval covering the first 15 years of a research career."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:19683-59049 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[19683,59049)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:19683-59049 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 19683 (included) and 59049 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:2187-6561 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[2187,6561)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:2187-6561 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 2187 (included) and 6561 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:243-729 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[243,729)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:243-729 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 243 (included) and 729 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:27-81 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[27,81)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:27-81 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 27 (included) and 81 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:3-9 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[3,9)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:3-9 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 3 (included) and 9 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:5-years-beginning a owl:NamedIndividual, time:Interval ; rdfs:label "5 years beginning"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:concernsResearchPeriod bido:5-years-beginning . """ ; rdfs:comment "The interval covering the first 5 years of a research career."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:6561-19683 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[6561,19683)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:6561-19683 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 6561 (included) and 19683 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:729-2187 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[729,2187)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:729-2187 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 729 (included) and 2187 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:81-243 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[81,243)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:81-243 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 81 (included) and 243 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:9-27 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "[9,27)" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:9-27 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The citation interval between 9 (included) and 27 (excluded)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:a-r-ts-rejps a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Reject, Pre-Screening (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-r-ts ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-r-ts-rejps . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Reject, Pre-Screening' in a discrete scale from 'Accept' to 'Reject, Two Strikes' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:a-r-ts-rejts a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Reject, Two Strikes (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-r-ts ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-r-ts-rejts . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Reject, Two Strikes' in a discrete scale from 'Accept' to 'Reject, Two Strikes' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:accordingTo a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "according to"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-numeric-bibliometric-data . :my-organization a prov:Agent . """ ; rdfs:comment "The relation between a bibliometric data in time situation and an agent who provided such data."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range prov:Agent ; rdfs:subPropertyOf ns1:withinContext, prov:wasAttributedTo ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:author-citation-count a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom foaf:Person ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "author citation count" ; vann:example """ :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:author-citation-count ; bido:hasNumericValue "56"^^xsd:integer . """ ; rdfs:comment "The count of all the citation received by all the papers of a certain author." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:average-of-reviews-per-paper a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:unionOf ( ns3:AcademicEvent ns2:Expression ) ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "average number of reviews per paper" ; vann:example """ :my-academic-event a swc:AcademicEvent ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-numeric-bibliometric-data . :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:average-of-reviews-per-paper ; bido:hasNumericValue "3.5"^^xsd:float . """ ; rdfs:comment "A measure indicating how many reviewers has been used for each paper submitted to a venue." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:concernsResearchPeriod a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "concerns research period"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:concernsResearchPeriod bido:5-years-beginning . bido:5-years-beginning a time:Interval . """ ; rdfs:comment "The relation between a research career category and the research period that caracterises it."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range time:Interval ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:conference-management-toolkit a bido:ScholarlyVenueManagementSystem, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Conference Management Toolkit" ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:conference-management-toolkit . """ ; rdfs:comment "A free conference management service sponsored by Microsoft Research." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:core-a-star a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "A*" ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:core-conference-ranking ; bido:isHigherThan bido:core-a ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:core-a-star . """ ; rdfs:comment "The CORE category for a flagship conference, a leading venue in a discipline area." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:demo-paper-accepted a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:unionOf ( ns3:AcademicEvent ns2:Expression ) ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "number of demo paper accepted" ; vann:example """ :my-academic-event a swc:AcademicEvent ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-numeric-bibliometric-data . :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:demoà-paper-accepted ; bido:hasNumericValue "6"^^xsd:float . """ ; rdfs:comment "A measure indicating how many demo papers has been accepted for publication or presentation in the venue." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-10-1 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "1 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "1"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-1 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 1 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-10-2 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "2 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "2"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-2 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 2 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-10-3 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "3 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "3"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-3 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 3 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-10-4 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "4 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "4"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-4 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 4 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-10-6 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "6 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "6"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-6 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 6 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-10-7 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "7 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "7"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-7 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 7 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-10-8 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "8 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "8"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-8 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 8 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-10-9 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "9 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "9"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-9 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 9 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:double-blind-peer-review a bido:PeerReviewType, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "double blind peer review" ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:double-blind-peer-review . """ ; rdfs:comment "A review process where the identity of the authors is concealed from the reviewers, and vice versa." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:e-index a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom foaf:Person ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "e-index" ; vann:example """ :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:e-index ; bido:hasNumericValue "3"^^xsd:integer . """ ; rdfs:comment "An h-index complement, aimed at considering the contributions of excess citations, which are mainly from highly cited papers. It is necessary, especially for evaluating highly cited scientists or for precisely comparing the scientific output of a group of scientists having an identical h-index." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:easychair a bido:ScholarlyVenueManagementSystem, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "EasyChair" ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:easychair . """ ; rdfs:comment "A conference management system that is flexible, easy to use, and has many features to make it suitable for various conference models. It is currently probably the most commonly used conference management system." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:exponential a bido:Growth, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "exponential"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasGrowth bido:exponential . """ ; rdfs:comment "An exponential growth pattern characterising the slope of the curve."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:external-reviewers-involved a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:unionOf ( ns3:AcademicEvent ns2:Expression ) ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "number of external reviewers involved" ; vann:example """ :my-academic-event a swc:AcademicEvent ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-numeric-bibliometric-data . :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:external-reviews-involved ; bido:hasNumericValue "20"^^xsd:float . """ ; rdfs:comment "A measure indicating how many external reviewers have been involved in the reviewing phase." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:flat a bido:Trend, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "flat"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasTrend bido:flat . """ ; rdfs:comment "A constant trend characterising the curve."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:full-papers-accepted a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:unionOf ( ns3:AcademicEvent ns2:Expression ) ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "number of full paper accepted" ; vann:example """ :my-academic-event a swc:AcademicEvent ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-numeric-bibliometric-data . :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:full-papers-accepted ; bido:hasNumericValue "30"^^xsd:float . """ ; rdfs:comment "A measure indicating how many full papers has been accepted for publication or presentation in the venue." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:h-index a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom foaf:Person ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "h-index" ; vann:example """ :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:h-index ; bido:hasNumericValue "8"^^xsd:integer . """ ; rdfs:comment "An index that attempts to measure both the productivity and impact of the published work of a scientist or scholar. The index is based on the set of the scientist's most cited papers and the number of citations that they have received in other publications. The index can also be applied to the productivity and impact of a group of scientists, such as a department or university or country, as well as a scholarly journal." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasConfidenceValue a owl:DatatypeProperty ; rdfs:label "has confidence value"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:acl-1-5-acl1 . bido:acl-1-5-acl1 a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "1"^^xsd:int . """ ; rdfs:comment "The confidence value of expertise in the review topic given by the reviwer."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range rdfs:Literal ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasCurve a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "has curve"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasTrend bido:increasing ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:premature-deceleration . """ ; rdfs:comment "The relation between a research career category and the curve that characterises it."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:Curve ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasGrowth a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "has growth"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasGrowth bido:exponential . """ ; rdfs:comment "The relation between the slope and the related growth."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:Slope ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:Growth ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "has order of magnitude"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:243-729 . bido:243-729 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude . """ ; rdfs:comment "The relation between a research career category and the order of magnitude of the citation distribution that characterises it."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:OrderOfMagnitude ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasRatingValue a owl:DatatypeProperty ; rdfs:label "has rating value"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-n2-p2-neg1 . bido:dis-n2-p2-neg1 a bido:ReviewRatingValue ; bido:hasRatingValue "-1"^^xsd:int . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value of the rating given to a review."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:ReviewRatingValue ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range rdfs:Literal ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasSlope a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "has slope"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasStrength bido:low ; bido:hasGrowth bido:exponential . """ ; rdfs:comment "The relation between a research career category and the slope of the curve that characterises it."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:Slope ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasStrength a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "has strength"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasStrength bido:low . """ ; rdfs:comment "The relation between the slope and the related strength."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:Slope ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:Strength ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:high a bido:Strength, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "high"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasStrength bido:high . """ ; rdfs:comment "A high strength characterizing the slope of the curve."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:isDefinedIn a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "is defined in ranking"@en ; vann:example """ bido:core-a a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:core-conference-ranking . """ ; rdfs:comment "A relation between a ranking category and the ranking that defines it."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:CategorialBibliometricData ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range skos:ConceptScheme ; rdfs:subPropertyOf skos:inScheme ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:isHigherThan a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "is higher than"@en ; vann:example """ bido:core-a a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory ; bido:isHigherThan bido:core-b . bido:core-b a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory . """ ; rdfs:comment "A relation between a ranking category and another that is less important."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:CategorialBibliometricData ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:CategorialBibliometricData ; owl:inverseOf bido:isLowerThan ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:journal-impact-factor a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom ns2:Journal ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "journal impact factor" ; vann:example """ :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:journal-impact-factor ; bido:hasNumericValue "2.464"^^xsd:float . """ ; rdfs:comment "A measure reflecting the average number of citations to recent articles published in the journal. It is frequently used as a proxy for the relative importance of a journal within its field, with journals with higher impact factors deemed to be more important than those with lower ones." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:linear a bido:Growth, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "linear"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasGrowth bido:linear . """ ; rdfs:comment "A linear growth pattern characterizing the slope of the curve."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:logarithmic a bido:Growth, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "logarithmic"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasGrowth bido:logarithmic . """ ; rdfs:comment "A logarithmic growth pattern characterizing the slope of the curve."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:low a bido:Strength, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "low"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasStrength bido:low . """ ; rdfs:comment "A low strength characterizing the slope of the curve."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:median-acceleration a bido:AccelerationPoint, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "median acceleration"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:median-acceleration . """ ; rdfs:comment "An acceleration point located in the middle of the considered research period."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:median-deceleration a bido:AccelerationPoint, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "median deceleration"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:median-deceleration . """ ; rdfs:comment "A deceleration point located in the middle of the considered research period."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:moderate a bido:Strength, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "moderate"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasStrength bido:moderate . """ ; rdfs:comment "A moderate strength characterizing the slope of the curve."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:none a bido:AccelerationPoint, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "none"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:none . """ ; rdfs:comment "No significant acceleration or deceleration point along the curve."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:open-peer-review a bido:PeerReviewType, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "open peer review"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:open-peer-review . """ ; rdfs:comment "A review process where the identity of the authors and the reviewers is known."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:overdue-acceleration a bido:AccelerationPoint, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "overdue acceleration"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:overdue-acceleration . """ ; rdfs:comment "An acceleration point occurring late in the considered research period."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:overdue-deceleration a bido:AccelerationPoint, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "overdue deceleration"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:overdue-deceleration . """ ; rdfs:comment "A deceleration point occurring late in the considered research period."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:polynomial a bido:Growth, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "polynomial"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasGrowth bido:polynomial . """ ; rdfs:comment "A polynomial growth pattern characterizing the slope of the curve."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:poster-papers-accepted a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:unionOf ( ns3:AcademicEvent ns2:Expression ) ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "number of poster paper accepted"@en ; vann:example """ :my-academic-event a swc:AcademicEvent ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-numeric-bibliometric-data . :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:poster-papers-accepted ; bido:hasNumericValue "25"^^xsd:float . """ ; rdfs:comment "A measure indicating how many poster papers has been accepted for publication/presentation in the venue."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:premature-acceleration a bido:AccelerationPoint, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "premature acceleration"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:premature-acceleration . """ ; rdfs:comment "An acceleration point occurring early in the considered research period."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:premature-deceleration a bido:AccelerationPoint, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "premature deceleration"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:premature-deceleration . """ ; rdfs:comment "A deceleration point occurring early in the considered research period."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:short-papers-accepted a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:unionOf ( ns3:AcademicEvent ns2:Expression ) ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "number of short paper accepted"@en ; vann:example """ :my-academic-event a swc:AcademicEvent ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-numeric-bibliometric-data . :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:short-papers-accepted ; bido:hasNumericValue "35"^^xsd:float . """ ; rdfs:comment "A measure indicating how many short papers has been accepted for publication or presentation in the venue."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:single-blind-peer-review a bido:PeerReviewType, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "single blind peer review"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:single-blind-peer-review . """ ; rdfs:comment "A review process where the identity of the reviewers is concealed from the authors."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:submissions-sent-for-review a [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:unionOf ( ns3:AcademicEvent ns2:Expression ) ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasMeasure ] ], bido:BibliometricMeasure, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "number of submission sent for review"@en ; vann:example """ :my-academic-event a swc:AcademicEvent ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-numeric-bibliometric-data . :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:submissions-sent-for-review ; bido:hasNumericValue "200"^^xsd:float . """ ; rdfs:comment "The number of submitted papers assigned to reviewers for revision."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:to-10-continuous a bido:ReviewRatingScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "0 to 10 continuos review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-review-rating-value . :my-review-rating-value bido:isDefinedIn bido:to-10-continuous . """ ; rdfs:comment "A continuous review rating scale, ranging from 0 to 10."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:to-15-continuous a bido:ReviewRatingScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "0 to 15 continuos review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-review-rating-value . :my-review-rating-value bido:isDefinedIn bido:to-15-continuous . """ ; rdfs:comment "A continuous review rating scale, ranging from 0 to 15."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:to-5-continuous a bido:ReviewRatingScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "0 to 5 continuos review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-review-rating-value . :my-review-rating-value bido:isDefinedIn bido:to-5-continuous . """ ; rdfs:comment "A continuous review rating scale, ranging from 0 to 5."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . rdfs:comment a owl:AnnotationProperty . rdfs:isDefinedBy a owl:AnnotationProperty . rdfs:label a owl:AnnotationProperty . owl:Thing a owl:Class . owl:versionInfo a owl:AnnotationProperty . skos:closeMatch a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "has close match"@en ; rdfs:comment "A relation between two concepts that are sufficiently similar that they can be used interchangeably in some information retrieval applications."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy skos: . a owl:Ontology ; rdfs:label "BiDO Research Career Category module (BiDO-Research-Career-Category)" ; dc:contributor "Sebastian Barzaghi (https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0799-1527)"^^xsd:string ; dc:creator "Enrico Motta (https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0015-1952)", "Francesco Osborne (https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6557-3131)", "Silvio Peroni (http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0530-4305)" ; dc:date "2026-08-14" ; dc:description """ This is an additional module of BiDO that extends the class `bido:CategorialBibliometricData` of the core module with specific categories describing the research career of people. ![The architecture of BiDO-Research-Career-Category module.](bido-research-career-category.png) These categories are described by the class `bido:ResearchCareerCategory`, which is characterised by four specific dimensions that have been used by our algorithm to cluster citation data: * the _research period considered_, i.e., the interval of research years that the algorithm is taking into consideration (e.g., the first 5/10 years); * the _curve_, i.e., the specific shape proper to the clusters identified by the algorithm, which is characterised by a trend (flat/increasing/decreasing) and, in the latter two cases, by an acceleration or deceleration point (none or premature, median, overdue acceleration/deceleration); * the _slope_ of such curve, in terms of strength (low/moderate/high) and kind of growth (linear/polynomial/exponential/logarithmic); * the _order of magnitude_, which categorises the number of citations received in the considered period according to a uniform model of common-sense estimation [1], which describes intervals of half-order of magnitude – i.e., “[0,1)”, “[1,3)”, “[3,9)”, “[9,27)”, “[27,81)”, “[81,243)”, “[243,729)”, etc. """@en ; dc:title "The BiDO Research Career Category module (BiDO-Research-Career-Category)" ; dcterms:bibliographicCitation "Osborne, F., Peroni, S., Motta, E. (2014). Clustering Citation Distributions for Semantic Categorization and Citation Prediction. In Proceedings of the 4th Workshop on Linked Science (LISC 2014): 24–35. http://ceur-ws.org/Vol-1282/lisc2014_submission_9.pdf" ; dcterms:created "2014-08-11" ; dcterms:issued "2014-08-11" ; dcterms:license ; dcterms:modified "2026-08-14" ; dcterms:publisher ; dcterms:source ; bibo:doi "https://doi.org/10.25504/FAIRsharing.d7f0a9" ; bibo:status ; vann:changes """ * **v1.1.1**: Added new documentation, including annotation properties (e.g., `bibo:doi`, `schema:codeRepository`, etc.), term properties (e.g., `vann:example`, `vs:term_status`, etc.), exemplary competency questions with their respective SPARQL queries, and a Grafoo diagram. """@en ; vann:preferredNamespacePrefix "bido"@en ; vann:preferredNamespaceUri "http://purl.org/spar/bido"@en ; rdfs:seeAlso ; owl:backwardCompatibleWith ; owl:imports ; owl:priorVersion ; owl:versionIRI ; owl:versionInfo "1.1.1" ; foaf:logo ; schema:codeRepository ; schema:includedInDataCatalog . a owl:Ontology ; rdfs:label "BiDO Review Measures module (BiDO-Review-Measures)" ; dc:contributor "Aliaksandr Birukou (https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4925-9131)"^^xsd:string, "Sebastian Barzaghi (https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0799-1527)"^^xsd:string ; dc:creator "Idafen Santana-Pérez (https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8296-8629)"^^xsd:string, "María Poveda-Villalón (https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3587-0367)"^^xsd:string, "Silvio Peroni (http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0530-4305)"^^xsd:string ; dc:date "2026-08-14"^^xsd:string ; dc:description """ This module of BiDO describes a list of possible reviews measures tha can be used to define bibliometric data of scholarly venues such as conferences, workshops, and journals. ![The architecture of the BiDO-Review-Measures module.](bido-review-measures.png) """@en ; dc:title "BiDO Review Measures module (BiDO-Review-Measures)" ; dcterms:created "2015-07-13" ; dcterms:issued "2015-07-13" ; dcterms:license ; dcterms:modified "2026-08-14" ; dcterms:publisher ; dcterms:source ; bibo:doi "https://doi.org/10.25504/FAIRsharing.d7f0a9" ; bibo:status ; vann:changes """ * **v1.1.1**: Added new documentation, including annotation properties (e.g., `bibo:doi`, `schema:codeRepository`, etc.), term properties (e.g., `vann:example`, `vs:term_status`, etc.), exemplary competency questions with their respective SPARQL queries, and a Grafoo diagram. Fixed typo `continuos` in URIs `bido:to-15-continuous`, `bido:to-5-continuous` and `bido:to-10-continuous`. Fixed usage of `bido:isDefinedIn`, previously used only on certain individuals but often replaced by `skos:inScheme`. """@en ; vann:preferredNamespacePrefix "bido"@en ; vann:preferredNamespaceUri "http://purl.org/spar/bido"@en ; rdfs:seeAlso ; owl:backwardCompatibleWith ; owl:imports ; owl:priorVersion ; owl:versionIRI ; owl:versionInfo "1.1.1"^^xsd:string ; foaf:logo ; schema:codeRepository ; schema:includedInDataCatalog . a owl:Ontology ; rdfs:label "BiDO Standard Bibliometric Measures module (BiDO-Standard-Bibliometric-Measures)" ; dc:contributor "Sebastian Barzaghi (https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0799-1527)"^^xsd:string ; dc:creator "Enrico Motta (https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0015-1952)", "Francesco Osborne (https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6557-3131)", "Silvio Peroni (http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0530-4305)" ; dc:date "2026-09-13" ; dc:description """ This module of BiDO describes a list of possible bibliometric measures tha can be used to define bibliometric data of publication-related entities, e.g.: h-index, e-index, journal impact factor, author citation count. ![The architecture of the BiDO-Standard-Bibliometric-Measures module.](bido-standard-bibliometric-measures.png) """@en ; dc:title "BiDO Standard Bibliometric Measures module (BiDO-Standard-Bibliometric-Measures)" ; dcterms:bibliographicCitation "Osborne, F., Peroni, S., Motta, E. (2014). Clustering Citation Distributions for Semantic Categorization and Citation Prediction. In Proceedings of the 4th Workshop on Linked Science (LISC 2014): 24–35. http://ceur-ws.org/Vol-1282/lisc2014_submission_9.pdf" ; dcterms:created "2015-07-15" ; dcterms:issued "2015-07-15" ; dcterms:license ; dcterms:modified "2026-09-13" ; dcterms:publisher ; dcterms:source ; bibo:doi "https://doi.org/10.25504/FAIRsharing.d7f0a9" ; bibo:status ; vann:changes """ * **v1.1.1**: Added new documentation, including annotation properties (e.g., `bibo:doi`, `schema:codeRepository`, etc.), term properties (e.g., `vann:example`, `vs:term_status`, etc.), exemplary competency questions with their respective SPARQL queries, and a Grafoo diagram. * **v1.1.2**: Fixed `tvc:atTime` range, adding `time:TemporalEntity`. """@en ; vann:preferredNamespacePrefix "bido"@en ; vann:preferredNamespaceUri "http://purl.org/spar/bido"@en ; rdfs:seeAlso ; owl:backwardCompatibleWith ; owl:imports ; owl:priorVersion ; owl:versionIRI ; owl:versionInfo "1.1.1"^^xsd:string ; foaf:logo ; schema:codeRepository ; schema:includedInDataCatalog . bido:ConferenceRanking a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "conference ranking"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:core-a . bido:core-a bido:isDefinedIn bido:core-conference-ranking . bido:core-conference-ranking a bido:ConferenceRanking . """ ; rdfs:comment "A ranking involving conferences that is composed by categories identifying different rankings."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf skos:ConceptScheme ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:ReviewerConfidenceScale a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "reviewer confidence scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:acl-1-5-acl1 . bido:acl-1-5-acl1 a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:acl-1-5 . bido:acl-1-5 a bido:DiscreteReviewerConfidenceScale . bido:DiscreteReviewerConfidenceScale rdfs:subClassOf bido:ReviewerConfidenceScale . """ ; rdfs:comment "A scale defining the confidence of a reviewer for a given topic."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf skos:ConceptScheme ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:core-a a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "A" ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:core-conference-ranking ; bido:isHigherThan bido:core-b ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:core-a . """ ; rdfs:comment "The CORE category for an excellent conference, and highly respected in a discipline area."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:core-b a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "B" ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:core-conference-ranking ; bido:isHigherThan bido:core-c ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:core-b . """ ; rdfs:comment "The CORE category for a good conference, and well regarded in a discipline area."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:core-c a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "C" ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:core-conference-ranking ; bido:isHigherThan bido:core-unranked ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:core-c . """ ; rdfs:comment "The CORE category for other ranked conference venues that meet minimum standards."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:core-unranked a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "unranked"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:core-conference-ranking ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:core-unranked . """ ; rdfs:comment "The CORE category for a conference for which no ranking decision has been made."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:decreasing a bido:Trend, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "decreasing" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasTrend bido:decreasing . """ ; rdfs:comment "A decreasing trend characterizing the curve." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasAccelerationPoint a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "has acceleration point" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:premature-deceleration . bido:premature-deceleration a bido:AccelerationPoint . """ ; rdfs:comment "The relation between a curve and its acceleration point." ; rdfs:domain bido:Curve ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:AccelerationPoint ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasTrend a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "has trend" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasTrend bido:increasing . bido:increasing a bido:Trend . """ ; rdfs:comment "The relation between a curve and its trend." ; rdfs:domain bido:Curve ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:Trend ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:increasing a bido:Trend, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "increasing" ; vann:example """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasTrend bido:increasing . """ ; rdfs:comment "An increasing trend characterizing the curve." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:isLowerThan a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "is lower than"@en ; vann:example """ bido:core-b a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory ; bido:isLowerThan bido:core-a . bido:core-a a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory . """ ; rdfs:comment "A relation between a ranking category and another that is more important."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . ns2:Journal a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "journal"@en ; rdfs:comment "A scholarly periodical primarily devoted to the publication of original research papers."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ns2: . ns1:hasValue a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "has value"@en ; rdfs:comment "The relation between an entity and a value in time situation."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range ns1:ValueInTime . ns1:withinContext a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "within context"@en ; rdfs:comment "The relation between a value in time and the specific context within which the fact of the entity having the value is relevant."@en ; rdfs:domain ns1:ValueInTime ; rdfs:isDefinedBy . skos:Concept a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "concept"@en ; rdfs:comment "An idea or notion; a unit of thought."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy skos: . skos:inScheme a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "is in scheme"@en ; rdfs:comment "A relation between an entity and the concept scheme it is contained in."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy skos: . prov:wasAttributedTo a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "was attributed to"@en ; rdfs:comment "The relation between an entity ascribed to an agent and that agent."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy prov: ; rdfs:range prov:Agent . bido:DiscreteReviewerConfidenceScale a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "discrete reviewer confidence scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:acl-1-5-acl1 . bido:acl-1-5-acl1 a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:acl-1-5 . bido:acl-1-5 a bido:DiscreteReviewerConfidenceScale . """ ; rdfs:comment "A discrete scale defining the confidence of a reviewer for a given topic."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf bido:ReviewerConfidenceScale ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:NumericBibliometricData a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "numeric bibliometric data"@en ; vann:example """ :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:journal-impact-factor ; bido:hasNumericValue "2.464"^^xsd:float . """ ; rdfs:comment "Bibliometric data represented by numbers. Such numeric data are those characterised by a certain integer or float value related to a particular bibliometric measure."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:cardinality "1"^^xsd:nonNegativeInteger ; owl:onProperty bido:hasMeasure ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:cardinality "1"^^xsd:nonNegativeInteger ; owl:onProperty bido:hasNumericValue ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:cardinality "1"^^xsd:nonNegativeInteger ; owl:onProperty bido:hasNumericValue ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:cardinality "1"^^xsd:nonNegativeInteger ; owl:onProperty bido:hasNumericValue ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:cardinality "1"^^xsd:nonNegativeInteger ; owl:onProperty bido:hasMeasure ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:cardinality "1"^^xsd:nonNegativeInteger ; owl:onProperty bido:hasMeasure ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:cardinality "1"^^xsd:nonNegativeInteger ; owl:onProperty bido:hasNumericValue ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:cardinality "1"^^xsd:nonNegativeInteger ; owl:onProperty bido:hasNumericValue ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:cardinality "1"^^xsd:nonNegativeInteger ; owl:onProperty bido:hasMeasure ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:cardinality "1"^^xsd:nonNegativeInteger ; owl:onProperty bido:hasMeasure ], bido:BibliometricData ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:ScholarlyVenueManagementSystem a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "scholarly venue management system"@en ; vann:example """ :my-academic-event a swc:AcademicEvent ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:conference-management-toolkit . bido:conference-management-toolkit a bido:ScholarlyVenueManagementSystem . """ ; rdfs:comment "A venue management system (such as a conference management system, or a journal management system) that can be used for managing scholarly venues."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:unionOf ( ns3:AcademicEvent ns2:Expression ) ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ], bido:CategorialBibliometricData ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:acl-1-5-acl1 a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "1 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "1"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:acl-1-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:acl-1-5-acl1 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 1 in a discrete scale from 1 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:acl-1-5-acl1, bido:ex-null-null . bido:acl-1-5-acl2 a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "2 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "2"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:acl-1-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:acl-1-5-acl2 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 2 in a discrete scale from 1 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:acl-1-5-acl2, bido:ex-null-low . bido:acl-1-5-acl3 a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "3 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "3"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:acl-1-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:acl-1-5-acl3 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 3 in a discrete scale from 1 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:acl-1-5-acl3, bido:ex-null-med . bido:acl-1-5-acl4 a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "4 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "4"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:acl-1-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:acl-1-5-acl4 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 4 in a discrete scale from 1 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:acl-1-5-acl4, bido:ex-null-high . bido:acl-1-5-acl5 a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "5 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "5"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:acl-1-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:acl-1-5-acl5 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 5 in a discrete scale from 1 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:acl-1-5-acl5, bido:ex-null-exp . bido:dis-0-5-2 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "2 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "2"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-5-2 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 2 in a discrete scale from 0 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:sa-sr-bl-wrej, bido:sa-sr-nb-wrej . bido:ex-null-exp a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Expert (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)"@en ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "4"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:ex-null ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:ex-null-exp . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Expert' in a discrete scale from 'Expert' to 'Null' for rating reviewers' confidence."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:acl-1-5-acl5, bido:ex-null-exp . bido:ex-null-high a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "High (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)"@en ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "3"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:ex-null ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:ex-null-high . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'High' in a discrete scale from 'Expert' to 'Null' for rating reviewers' confidence."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:acl-1-5-acl4, bido:ex-null-high . bido:ex-null-low a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Low (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)"@en ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "1"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:ex-null ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:ex-null-low . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Low' in a discrete scale from 'Expert' to 'Null' for rating reviewers' confidence."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:acl-1-5-acl2, bido:ex-null-low . bido:ex-null-med a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Medium (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)"@en ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "2"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:ex-null ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:ex-null-med . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Medium' in a discrete scale from 'Expert' to 'Null' for rating reviewers' confidence."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:acl-1-5-acl3, bido:ex-null-med . bido:ex-null-null a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Null (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)"@en ; bido:hasConfidenceValue "0"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:ex-null ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:ex-null-null . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Null' in a discrete scale from 'Expert' to 'Null' for rating reviewers' confidence."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:acl-1-5-acl1, bido:ex-null-null . bido:sa-sr-bl-wrej a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Weak Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-bl ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-bl-wrej . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Weak Reject' in a discrete scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:dis-0-5-2, bido:sa-sr-nb-wrej . bido:sa-sr-nb-wrej a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Weak Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-nb ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-nb-wrej . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Weak Reject' in a discrete scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:dis-0-5-2, bido:sa-sr-bl-wrej . time:TemporalEntity a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "temporal entity"@en ; rdfs:comment "A temporal interval or instant."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy time: . prov:Agent a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "agent"@en ; rdfs:comment "Something that bears some form of responsibility for an activity taking place, for the existence of an entity, or for another agent's activity."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy prov: . a owl:Ontology ; rdfs:label "BiDO Core module (BiDO-Core)"@en ; dc:contributor "Sebastian Barzaghi (https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0799-1527)"^^xsd:string ; dc:creator "Enrico Motta (https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0015-1952)"^^xsd:string, "Francesco Osborne (https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6557-3131)"^^xsd:string, "Silvio Peroni (http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0530-4305)"^^xsd:string ; dc:date "2026-08-14", "2026-09-13" ; dc:description """ The core module of BiDO allows us to describe any entity and the related bibliometric data (through the property `bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime`) at a certain time (i.e., `tvc:atTime`, a property defined by the imported TVC ontology for specifying temporal instants or intervals) and according to a certain agent (through the property `bido:accordingTo`, which is a sub-property of `prov:wasAttributedTo` and allows us to indicate the agent responsible for such bibliometric data). ![The architecture of the BiDO-Core module.](bido-core.png) Two alternative kinds of bibliometric data are specifiable (through the property `bido:withBibliometricData`) in BiDO: numeric data and categorial data. Numeric data are those characterised by a certain integer or float value related to a particular bibliometric measure. Some of these measures – i.e., h-index, author citation count, e-index, and journal impact factor – are available in a particular module of BiDO responsible for describing the most common bibliometric measures. """@en ; dc:title "BiDO Core module (BiDO-Core)"@en ; dcterms:bibliographicCitation "Osborne, F., Peroni, S., Motta, E. (2014). Clustering Citation Distributions for Semantic Categorization and Citation Prediction. In Proceedings of the 4th Workshop on Linked Science (LISC 2014): 24–35. http://ceur-ws.org/Vol-1282/lisc2014_submission_9.pdf" ; dcterms:created "2015-07-14" ; dcterms:issued "2015-07-14" ; dcterms:license ; dcterms:modified "2026-08-14", "2026-09-13" ; dcterms:publisher ; dcterms:source ; bibo:doi "https://doi.org/10.25504/FAIRsharing.d7f0a9" ; bibo:status ; vann:changes """ * **v1.2.1**: Added new documentation, including annotation properties (e.g., `bibo:doi`, `schema:codeRepository`, etc.), term properties (e.g., `vann:example`, `vs:term_status`, etc.), exemplary competency questions with their respective SPARQL queries, and a Grafoo diagram. """@en, """ * **v1.2.1**: Added new documentation, including annotation properties (e.g., `bibo:doi`, `schema:codeRepository`, etc.), term properties (e.g., `vann:example`, `vs:term_status`, etc.), exemplary competency questions with their respective SPARQL queries, and a Grafoo diagram. * **v1.2.2**: Fixed `tvc:atTime` range, adding `time:TemporalEntity`. """@en ; vann:preferredNamespacePrefix "bido"@en ; vann:preferredNamespaceUri "http://purl.org/spar/bido"@en ; rdfs:seeAlso ; owl:backwardCompatibleWith , ; owl:imports ; owl:priorVersion , ; owl:versionIRI , ; owl:versionInfo "1.2.1"^^xsd:string, "1.2.2"^^xsd:string ; foaf:logo ; schema:codeRepository ; schema:includedInDataCatalog . bido:BibliometricData a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "bibliometric data", "bibliometric data"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-bibliometric-data . :my-bibliometric-data a bido:BibliometricData . """ ; rdfs:comment "Any kind of bibliometric data. In particular, they are organised according two sub-concepts: numeric data and categorial data.", "Any kind of bibliometric data. In particular, they are organised according two sub-concepts: numeric data and categorial data."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:BibliometricDataInTime a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "bibliometric data in time", "bibliometric data in time"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-bibliometric-data . """ ; rdfs:comment "A particular situation that describes a bibliometric data a person, an article, or any other publication-related entity may have, that can be restricted to a particular time interval.", "A particular situation that describes a bibliometric data a person, an article, or any other publication-related entity may have, that can be restricted to a particular time interval."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom bido:BibliometricMeasure ; owl:onProperty ns1:withValue ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom bido:BibliometricMeasure ; owl:onProperty ns1:withValue ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom time:Interval ; owl:onProperty ns1:atTime ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom bido:BibliometricMeasure ; owl:onProperty ns1:withValue ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom time:Interval ; owl:onProperty ns1:atTime ], [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom time:Interval ; owl:onProperty ns1:atTime ], ns1:ValueInTime ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:PeerReviewType a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "peer review type"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:double-blind-peer-review . :double-blind-peer-review a bido:PeerReviewType . """ ; rdfs:comment "A type of of peer review process, such as 'double-blind' or 'open'."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:unionOf ( ns3:AcademicEvent ns2:Expression ) ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ], bido:CategorialBibliometricData ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:Slope a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "slope"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-career-activity a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasStrength bido:low ; bido:hasGrowth bido:logarithmic . """ ; rdfs:comment "The slope of a curve, in terms of strength (low/moderate/high) and kind of growth (linear/polynomial/exponential/logarithmic)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:a-na-wr a bido:DiscreteReviewRatingScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Approved to Not Approved review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-na-wr-appwr . bido:a-na-wr-appwr bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-na-wr . """ ; rdfs:comment "Discrete scale from 'Approved' to 'Not Approved', including Aprproved With Reservations."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:a-r-ts-majrev a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Major revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-r-ts ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-r-ts-majrev . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Major revision' in a discrete scale from 'Accept' to 'Reject, Two Strikes' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:dis-0-10-5, bido:dis-n2-p2-0, bido:sa-sr-bl-bdl . bido:dis-0-10-5 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "5 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "5"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-5 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 5 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-r-ts-majrev, bido:dis-n2-p2-0, bido:sa-sr-bl-bdl . bido:dis-n2-p2-0 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "0 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "0"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-n2-p2 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-n2-p2-0 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 0 in a discrete scale from -2 to 2 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-r-ts-majrev, bido:dis-0-10-5, bido:sa-sr-bl-bdl . bido:sa-sr-bl-bdl a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Borderline (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-bl ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-bl-bdl . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Borderline' in a discrete scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-r-ts-majrev, bido:dis-0-10-5, bido:dis-n2-p2-0 . ns1:atTime a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "at time"@en ; rdfs:comment "The relation between a situation and the particular temporal instant or time period in which the situation takes place."@en ; rdfs:domain ns1:ValueInTime ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range time:TemporalEntity . bido:Curve a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "curve"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-career-activity a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasTrend bido:increasing ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:premature-deceleration . """ ; rdfs:comment "The specific shape proper to the clusters identified by the algorithm, which is characterised by a trend (flat/increasing/decreasing) and, in the latter two cases, by an acceleration or deceleration point (none or premature, median, overdue acceleration/deceleration)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:ResearchCareerCategory a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "research career category"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-career-activity a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:243-729 ; bido:concernsResearchPeriod bido:5-years-beginning . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasTrend bido:increasing ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:premature-deceleration . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasStrength bido:low ; bido:hasGrowth bido:logarithmic . """ ; rdfs:comment "Bibliometric data that includes categories describing the research career of people. Each of such categories is characterised by four specific dimensions: the research period considered, the curve of the choosed citation distribution, the slope of such curve, and the order of magnitude of the citation of such research period."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom foaf:Person ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ], bido:CategorialBibliometricData ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:ReviewRatingScale a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-review-rating-value . :my-review-rating-value bido:isDefinedIn bido:to-5-continuous . bido:to-5-continuous a bido:ReviewRatingScale . """ ; rdfs:comment "A scale defining the rating given by a reviewer for a specific scientific contribution."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf skos:ConceptScheme ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:Strength a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "strength"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-career-activity a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasStrength bido:low . bido:low a bido:Strength . """ ; rdfs:comment "A kind of strength - i.e., low/moderate/high - that can characterise a slope."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:Trend a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "trend"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-career-activity a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasTrend bido:increasing . bido:increasing a bido:Trend . """ ; rdfs:comment "The flat/decreasing/increasing trend characterising the curve."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:a-na-wr-appwr a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Approved with reservations (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-na-wr ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-na-wr-appwr . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Approved with Reservations' in a discrete scale from 'Approved' to 'Not Approved' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-r-ts-minrev, bido:dis-0-5-3, bido:sa-sr-bl-wacc, bido:sa-sr-nb-wacc . bido:a-r-ts-minrev a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Minor revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-r-ts ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-r-ts-minrev . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Minor revision' in a discrete scale from 'Accept' to 'Reject, Two Strikes' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-appwr, bido:dis-0-5-3, bido:sa-sr-bl-wacc, bido:sa-sr-nb-wacc . bido:dis-0-5-3 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "3 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "3"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-5-3 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 3 in a discrete scale from 0 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-appwr, bido:a-r-ts-minrev, bido:sa-sr-bl-wacc, bido:sa-sr-nb-wacc . bido:sa-sr-bl-wacc a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-bl ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-bl-wacc . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Weak Accept' in a discrete scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-appwr, bido:a-r-ts-minrev, bido:dis-0-5-3, bido:sa-sr-nb-wacc . bido:sa-sr-nb-wacc a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-nb ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-nb-wacc . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Weak Accept' in a discrete scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-appwr, bido:a-r-ts-minrev, bido:dis-0-5-3, bido:sa-sr-bl-wacc . ns1:withValue a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "with value"@en ; rdfs:comment "The relation between the value in time situation and the actual value held by the entity partaking in that situation."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range ns1:ValueInTime . skos:ConceptScheme a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "concept scheme"@en ; rdfs:comment "A SKOS concept scheme can be viewed as an aggregation of one or more SKOS concepts."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy skos: . foaf:Person a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "person"@en ; rdfs:comment "A person."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy foaf: . bido:ConferenceRankingCategory a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "conference ranking category"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:core-a . bido:core-a a bido:ConferenceRankingCategory . """ ; rdfs:comment "A category that can be used for ranking a conference according to the related ranking that defines it."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom ns3:AcademicEvent ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime ] ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:withBibliometricData ] ], bido:CategorialBibliometricData ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:Growth a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "growth"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-career-activity a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope . :my-slope a bido:Slope ; bido:hasGrowth bido:logarithmic . bido:logarithmic a bido:Growth . """ ; rdfs:comment "A kind of growth - i.e., linear/polynomial/exponential/logarithmic - that can characterise a slope."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:acl-1-5 a bido:DiscreteReviewerConfidenceScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:acl-1-5-acl1 . bido:acl-1-5-acl1 a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue, bido:isDefinedIn bido:acl-1-5 . """ ; rdfs:comment "Discrete scale from 1 to 5, used by Association for Computational Linguistics annual meetings."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:core-conference-ranking a bido:ConferenceRanking, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "CORE conference ranking"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:core-a . bido:core-a bido:isDefinedIn bido:core-conference-ranking . """ ; rdfs:comment "The CORE Conference Ranking (http://www.core.edu.au/index.php/conference-rankings) is an ongoing activity that provides assessments of major conferences in the computing disciplines.The rankings are managed by the CORE Executive Committee, with updates processed from time to time by a subcommittee established as needed."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-5-1 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "1 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "1"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-5-1 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 1 in a discrete scale from 0 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-napp, bido:a-r-ts-rej, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg1, bido:sa-sr-bl-rej, bido:sa-sr-nb-rej . bido:dis-0-5-4 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "4 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "4"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-5-4 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 4 in a discrete scale from 0 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-app, bido:a-r-ts-acc, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos1, bido:sa-sr-bl-acc, bido:sa-sr-nb-acc . bido:dis-n2-p2 a bido:DiscreteReviewRatingScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-n2-p2-0 . bido:dis-n2-p2-0 bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-n2-p2 . """ ; rdfs:comment "Discrete scale from -2 to 2, including 0."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-n2-p2-neg1 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "-1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "-1"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-n2-p2 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-n2-p2-neg1 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value -1 in a discrete scale from -2 to 2 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-napp, bido:a-r-ts-rej, bido:dis-0-5-1, bido:sa-sr-bl-rej, bido:sa-sr-nb-rej . bido:dis-n2-p2-pos1 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "1"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-n2-p2 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-n2-p2-pos1 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 1 in a discrete scale from -2 to 2 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-app, bido:a-r-ts-acc, bido:dis-0-5-4, bido:sa-sr-bl-acc, bido:sa-sr-nb-acc . bido:ex-null a bido:DiscreteReviewerConfidenceScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:ex-null-null . bido:ex-null-null a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:ex-null . """ ; rdfs:comment "Discrete scale from 'Expert' to 'Null', also represented in an scale from 4 to 0."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasNumericValue a owl:DatatypeProperty ; rdfs:label "has numeric value"@en ; vann:example """ :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasNumericValue "2.464"^^xsd:float . """ ; rdfs:comment "The actual value of the bibliometric data in consideration."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:NumericBibliometricData ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range [ a rdfs:Datatype ; owl:unionOf ( xsd:float xsd:integer ) ], [ a rdfs:Datatype ; owl:unionOf ( xsd:float xsd:integer ) ], [ a rdfs:Datatype ; owl:unionOf ( xsd:float xsd:integer ) ], [ a rdfs:Datatype ; owl:unionOf ( xsd:float xsd:integer ) ], [ a rdfs:Datatype ; owl:unionOf ( xsd:float xsd:integer ) ] ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:sa-sr-bl-acc a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-bl ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-bl-acc . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Accept' in a scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-app, bido:a-r-ts-acc, bido:dis-0-5-4, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos1, bido:sa-sr-nb-acc . bido:sa-sr-bl-rej a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-bl ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-bl-rej . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Reject' in a scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-napp, bido:a-r-ts-rej, bido:dis-0-5-1, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg1, bido:sa-sr-nb-rej . bido:sa-sr-nb-acc a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-nb ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-nb-acc . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Accept' in a scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-app, bido:a-r-ts-acc, bido:dis-0-10-10, bido:dis-0-5-4, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos1, bido:sa-sr-bl-acc . bido:sa-sr-nb-rej a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-nb ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-nb-rej . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Reject' in a scale from 'Strong Accept' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-napp, bido:a-r-ts-rej, bido:dis-0-10-0, bido:dis-0-5-1, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg1, bido:sa-sr-bl-rej . ns1:ValueInTime a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "value in time"@en ; rdfs:comment "A particular kind of time-indexed situation that represents a hub linking the entity having a particular value, the value itself and the temporal and contextual extents from which the entity-value relationship depends."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy . xsd:float a rdfs:Datatype . xsd:integer a rdfs:Datatype . bido:a-r-ts a bido:DiscreteReviewRatingScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-r-ts-acc . bido:a-r-ts-acc bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-r-ts . """ ; rdfs:comment "Discrete scale from 'Accept' to 'Reject', including pre-screening and two strikes rule."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-5 a bido:DiscreteReviewRatingScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-5-0 . bido:dis-0-5-0 bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-5 . """ ; rdfs:comment "Discrete scale from 0 to 5."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-5-0 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "0 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "0"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-5-0 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 0 in a discrete scale from 0 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-napp, bido:a-r-ts-rej, bido:dis-0-10-0, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg2, bido:sa-sr-bl-srej, bido:sa-sr-nb-srej . bido:dis-0-5-5 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "5 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "5"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-5 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-5-5 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 5 in a discrete scale from 0 to 5 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-app, bido:a-r-ts-acc, bido:dis-0-10-10, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos2, bido:sa-sr-bl-sacc, bido:sa-sr-nb-sacc . bido:dis-n2-p2-neg2 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "-2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "-2"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-n2-p2 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-n2-p2-neg2 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value -2 in a discrete scale from -2 to 2 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-napp, bido:a-r-ts-rej, bido:dis-0-10-0, bido:dis-0-5-0, bido:sa-sr-bl-srej, bido:sa-sr-nb-srej . bido:dis-n2-p2-pos2 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "2"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-n2-p2 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-n2-p2-pos2 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 2 in a discrete scale from -2 to 2 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-app, bido:a-r-ts-acc, bido:dis-0-10-10, bido:dis-0-5-5, bido:sa-sr-bl-sacc, bido:sa-sr-nb-sacc . bido:sa-sr-bl-sacc a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-bl ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-bl-sacc . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Strong Accept' in a scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-app, bido:a-r-ts-acc, bido:dis-0-10-10, bido:dis-0-5-5, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos2, bido:sa-sr-nb-sacc . bido:sa-sr-bl-srej a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-bl ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-bl-srej . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Strong Reject' in a scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-napp, bido:a-r-ts-rej, bido:dis-0-10-0, bido:dis-0-5-0, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg2, bido:sa-sr-nb-srej . bido:sa-sr-nb a bido:DiscreteReviewRatingScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-nb-sacc . bido:sa-sr-nb-sacc bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-nb . """ ; rdfs:comment "Discrete scale from Strong Reject to Strong Accept, excluding Bordeline"@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:sa-sr-nb-sacc a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-nb ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-nb-sacc . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Strong Accept' in a scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-app, bido:a-r-ts-acc, bido:dis-0-10-10, bido:dis-0-5-5, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos2, bido:sa-sr-bl-sacc . bido:sa-sr-nb-srej a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-nb ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-nb-srej . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Strong Reject' in a scale from 'Strong Reject' to 'Strong Accept' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-napp, bido:a-r-ts-rej, bido:dis-0-10-0, bido:dis-0-5-0, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg2, bido:sa-sr-bl-srej . bido:DiscreteReviewRatingScale a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "discrete review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-n2-p2-0 . bido:dis-n2-p2-0 bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-n2-p2 . bido:dis-n2-p2 a bido:DiscreteReviewRatingScale . """ ; rdfs:comment "A discrete scale defining the rating given by a reviewer for a specific scientific contribution."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf bido:ReviewRatingScale ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-10-0 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "0 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "0"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-0 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 0 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-napp, bido:a-r-ts-rej, bido:dis-0-5-0, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg2, bido:sa-sr-bl-srej, bido:sa-sr-nb-srej . bido:dis-0-10-10 a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "10 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)"@en ; bido:hasRatingValue "10"^^xsd:int ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-10 . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 10 in a discrete scale from 0 to 10 for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-app, bido:a-r-ts-acc, bido:dis-0-5-5, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos2, bido:sa-sr-bl-sacc, bido:sa-sr-nb-sacc . bido:sa-sr-bl a bido:DiscreteReviewRatingScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:sa-sr-bl-wrej . bido:sa-sr-bl-wre bido:isDefinedIn bido:sa-sr-bl . """ ; rdfs:comment "Discrete scale from Strong Reject to Strong Accept, including Bordeline"@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . time:Interval a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "interval"@en, "time interval"@en ; rdfs:comment "A temporal entity with an extent or duration."@en, "The interval of research years that it is taken into consideration (e.g., the first 5/10 years)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy time: ; rdfs:subClassOf time:TemporalEntity . bido:AccelerationPoint a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "acceleration point"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-career-activity a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve . :my-curve a bido:Curve ; bido:hasAccelerationPoint bido:premature-deceleration . bido:premature-deceleration a bido:AccelerationPoint . """ ; rdfs:comment "The acceleration or deceleration point (none or premature, median, overdue acceleration/deceleration) of the curve, if any."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:intersectionOf ( bido:Curve [ a owl:Restriction ; owl:allValuesFrom [ a owl:Class ; owl:oneOf ( bido:increasing bido:decreasing ) ] ; owl:onProperty bido:hasTrend ] ) ] ; owl:onProperty [ owl:inverseOf bido:hasAccelerationPoint ] ] ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:CategorialBibliometricData a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "categorial bibliometric data"@en ; vann:example """ :my-person a foaf:Person ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-categorial-bibliometric-data . :my-categorial-bibliometric-data a bido:CategorialBibliometricData . """, """ :my-research-category a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasCurve :my-curve ; bido:hasSlope :my-slope ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:243-729 ; bido:concernsResearchPeriod bido:5-years-beginning . bido:ResearchCareerCategory rdfs:subClassOf bido:CategorialBibliometricData . """ ; rdfs:comment "Categorical information that characterises publication-related entities from a bibliometric point of view."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf bido:BibliometricData, skos:Concept ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . ns2:Expression a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "expression" ; rdfs:comment "Any possible work such as journals, magazines, books, etc., created for scientific purposes and possibily related with review processes." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ns2: . ns3:AcademicEvent a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "academic event" ; rdfs:comment "Any academic event such as conferences, workshops, symposia." ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ns3: . bido:a-na-wr-app a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-na-wr ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-na-wr-app . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Approved' in a discrete scale from 'Approved' to 'Not Approved' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-r-ts-acc, bido:dis-0-10-10, bido:dis-0-5-4, bido:dis-0-5-5, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos1, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos2, bido:sa-sr-bl-acc, bido:sa-sr-bl-sacc, bido:sa-sr-nb-acc, bido:sa-sr-nb-sacc . bido:a-na-wr-napp a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-na-wr ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-na-wr-napp . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Not Approved' in a discrete scale from 'Approved' to 'Not Approved' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-r-ts-rej, bido:dis-0-10-0, bido:dis-0-5-0, bido:dis-0-5-1, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg1, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg2, bido:sa-sr-bl-rej, bido:sa-sr-bl-srej, bido:sa-sr-nb-rej, bido:sa-sr-nb-srej . bido:a-r-ts-acc a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-r-ts ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-r-ts-acc . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Accept' in a discrete scale from 'Accept' to 'Reject, Two Strikes' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-app, bido:dis-0-10-10, bido:dis-0-5-4, bido:dis-0-5-5, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos1, bido:dis-n2-p2-pos2, bido:sa-sr-bl-acc, bido:sa-sr-bl-sacc, bido:sa-sr-nb-acc, bido:sa-sr-nb-sacc . bido:a-r-ts-rej a bido:ReviewRatingValue, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)"@en ; bido:isDefinedIn bido:a-r-ts ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-r-ts-rej . """ ; rdfs:comment "The value 'Reject' in a discrete scale from 'Accept' to 'Reject, Two Strikes' for review rating."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:closeMatch bido:a-na-wr-napp, bido:dis-0-10-0, bido:dis-0-5-0, bido:dis-0-5-1, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg1, bido:dis-n2-p2-neg2, bido:sa-sr-bl-rej, bido:sa-sr-bl-srej, bido:sa-sr-nb-rej, bido:sa-sr-nb-srej . bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "reviewer confidence value"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:ex-null-null . bido:ex-null-null a bido:ReviewerConfidenceValue . """ ; rdfs:comment "The set of values compliant with a given reviewer confidence scale."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf bido:CategorialBibliometricData ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:dis-0-10 a bido:DiscreteReviewRatingScale, owl:NamedIndividual ; rdfs:label "Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:dis-0-10-1 . bido:dis-0-10-1 bido:isDefinedIn bido:dis-0-10 . """ ; rdfs:comment "Discrete scale from 0 to 10."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:OrderOfMagnitude a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "order of magnitude"@en ; vann:example """ :my-research-career-activity a bido:ResearchCareerCategory ; bido:hasOrderOfMagnitude bido:243-729 . bido:243-729 a bido:OrderOfMagnitude . """ ; rdfs:comment "A categorization of the number of citations received in the considered period according to a uniform model of common-sense estimation, which describes intervals of half-order of magnitude - i.e., “[0,1)”, “[1,3)”, “[3,9)”, “[9,27)”, “[27,81)”, “[81,243)”, “[243,729)”, etc."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:BibliometricMeasure a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "bibliometric measure", "bibliometric measure"@en ; vann:example """ :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:journal-impact-factor . bido:journal-impact-factor a bido:BibliometricMeasure . """ ; rdfs:comment "Any kind of measure related with a bibliometric data (e.g., h-index, e-index, journal impact factor).", "Any kind of measure related with a bibliometric data (e.g., h-index, e-index, journal impact factor)."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "holds bibliometric data in time", "holds bibliometric data in time"@en ; vann:example """ :my-journal a fabio:Journal ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-numeric-bibliometric-data . """ ; rdfs:comment "A relation between a person or any other publication-related entity and bibliometric data that the entity holds. The ontology permits one to specify the time period over which a bibliometric data is held, and the other contextual entities responsible for having provided such bibliometric data.", "The relation between a person or any other publication-related entity and bibliometric data that the entity holds. The ontology permits one to specify the time period over which a bibliometric data is held, and the other contextual entities responsible for having provided such bibliometric data.", "The relation between a person or any other publication-related entity and bibliometric data that the entity holds."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; rdfs:subPropertyOf ns1:hasValue ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable ; skos:note """ The ontology permits one to specify the time period over which a bibliometric data is held, and the other contextual entities responsible for having provided such bibliometric data. """@en . bido:withBibliometricData a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "with bibliometric data", "with bibliometric data"@en ; vann:example """ :my-journal a fabio:Journal ; bido:holdsBibliometricDataInTime :my-bibliometric-data-in-time . :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData :my-numeric-bibliometric-data . """ ; rdfs:comment "A relation between an entity's bibliometric data in time and a definition of the type of bibliometric data held by this entity.", "The relation between an entity's bibliometric data in time and a definition of the type of bibliometric data held by this entity.", "The relation between an entity's bibliometric data in time and a definition of the type of bibliometric data held by this entity."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:BibliometricData ; rdfs:subPropertyOf ns1:withValue ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:hasMeasure a owl:ObjectProperty ; rdfs:label "has measure", "has measure"@en ; vann:example """ :my-numeric-bibliometric-data a bido:NumericBibliometricData ; bido:hasMeasure bido:journal-impact-factor . """ ; rdfs:comment "The kind of measure related with a bibliometric data (e.g., h-index, e-index, journal impact factor).", "The relation between some bibliometric data and a measure (e.g., h-index, e-index, journal impact factor)."@en ; rdfs:domain bido:NumericBibliometricData ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:range bido:BibliometricMeasure ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable . bido:ReviewRatingValue a owl:Class ; rdfs:label "review rating value"@en ; vann:example """ :my-bibliometric-data-in-time a bido:BibliometricDataInTime ; tvc:atTime :my-time-interval ; bido:accordingTo :my-organization ; bido:withBibliometricData bido:a-r-ts-rejps . bido:a-r-ts-rejps a bido:ReviewRatingValue . """ ; rdfs:comment "The set of values compliant with a given review rating scale."@en ; rdfs:isDefinedBy ; rdfs:subClassOf bido:CategorialBibliometricData ; vs:term_status reg:statusStable .